Tackling Squeaky Floors: Why Screws Outperform Nails
April 3, 2025
Squeaky floors can be a homeowner's worst nightmare, disrupting peace and comfort. These persistent sounds often seem to come from nowhere, making it hard to identify the exact source. Fortunately, by understanding the common causes of squeaks and adopting the right solutions, you can significantly reduce—or even eliminate—the problem. One of the most effective methods is replacing nails with screws when securing flooring and structural components. Read the article below from our engineer, Matt Smith, to see why this simple switch can make all the difference.
Common Causes of Squeaky Floors
1). Nailed Particleboard Flooring
Particleboard flooring secured with nails is highly susceptible to movement, which leads to squeaks over time. The nails can gradually loosen, allowing the flooring to shift and create noise. The most effective remedy is to glue and screw the flooring. Screws provide a more secure, long-lasting hold than nails, minimizing movement and preventing squeaks.
2). Improperly Installed Strongbacks
Strongbacks, which provide additional support to joists, are essential for the stability of a floor. When not installed properly, they may rub against metal webs, causing annoying squeaks. Ensuring proper installation and using screws for secure attachment will keep strongbacks firmly in place, preventing unwanted noise.
3). Loosening Joist Hangers
Joist hangers support the floor joists, and if they become loose or improperly installed, they can move and cause squeaks. While using a CCN64 Collated Connector Nailer can help secure joist hangers, screws offer a far more reliable solution. They grip tighter and are less prone to loosening over time, ensuring the hangers remain silent and secure.
4). Services Rubbing Against Metal Webs
Water pipes and other services can rub against metal webs, creating squeaks as they shift. To avoid this, proper installation and securing of these services is crucial. Screws can help secure brackets and supports, keeping pipes and services in place and preventing the noise caused by unwanted movement.
5). Internal Wall Brackets Rubbing on Nails
Internal wall brackets secured with nails can rub against slots, resulting in squeaks. Switching to SDPW Deflector Screws instead of nails is a smart move. These screws are designed to provide a stronger hold and include a polymer sleeve specifically engineered to eliminate noise, ensuring a quieter home environment.
Why Screws Are the Superior Choice
When it comes to preventing squeaky floors, screws have several distinct advantages over nails:
- Superior Grip: Screws offer a more secure, tighter grip, reducing the chances of movement that can lead to squeaks.
- Long-Lasting Hold: Unlike nails, screws are less likely to loosen over time, keeping your flooring and structural components securely in place.
- Easy Installation: Screws are easy to install and, if necessary, remove, offering flexibility for repairs and adjustments.
- Reduced Movement: The threaded design of screws minimizes movement, a major cause of squeaks in flooring and structural components.
Conclusion
Squeaky floors can be a persistent annoyance, but understanding their causes and implementing effective solutions can help you enjoy a quieter, more comfortable home. By choosing screws over nails for flooring and structural components, you’ll benefit from a stronger grip, longer-lasting hold, and reduced movement—all of which work together to prevent squeaks. Take control of your floor's stability and say goodbye to those disruptive squeaks for good.
Structural Connections
Unmatched Quality from the Truss to the Foundation
With nearly 60 years of field and R&D experience, Simpson Strong-Tie® timber connectors are manufactured to the industry's highest standards. From framing angles to straps to heavy-duty joist hangers, we offer the most diverse product line so that you have the right product for the job.
Simpson Strong-Tie® connectors offer unmatched quality with laboratory and field testing, and are backed by our uncompromising commitment to customer service. As the company that built the connector industry, you can count on Simpson Strong-Tie® to work closely with builders, engineers and building officials to deliver innovative, building code-compliant solutions to help build safer, stronger structures economically. Download the Structural Connectors Overview Flyer.
Timber Connectors
From testing to service to availability, everything we do is engineered to ensure your project's success. With every product, you know you are getting the quality, value, service and on-time delivery that we have built our reputation on for the past 60 years.
From straps and ties to joist hangers and much more, Simpson Strong-Tie® structural connectors increase the strength and safety of timber-frame structures. Each connector is unique to Simpson Strong-Tie and is designed for specific applications without the need to adapt metal plating to suit a connection.
Steel Frame Connectors
From fully tested and engineered connectors and clips Simpson Strong-Tie® provides comprehensive structural solutions for cold-formed steel construction. From steel-to-steel connections to full-scale lateral solutions and curtain wall connectors, we remain committed to developing new technology that helps to advance the cold-formed steel industry.
Find out how Simpson Strong-Tie timber connectors can help you build the right way every day. Download the Cold-Fromed Steel Construction Connectors Catalogue.
